Topic: Rating a sunset picture (Page 1 of 1)

If zero is a picture without anything special about it, and ten is a picture that has something very special about it, knowning that sunset pictures are way common, how would you rate the picture below (clicking the thumb brings a 180kb-size image):

I'd give it a 3. It's lacking composition, and in a sunset composition is everything. The tree just blocks the sunset.

I love silhouettes, and the tree makes it a very non-typical sunset shot. 8.

I agree with you, Das, but there's a bit too much tree for my taste. I'll give it a 6.

Thanks for the comments.
I like the branches. This time of year is a nice time to take pictures that otherwise would be impossible, when the leaves avoid being able to see the background better.