Preserved Topic: the 5k +++winners+++ (Page 1 of 1)

lookie, doc has got the 2nd place in the function top 10.

congrats, doc, very nice work!

here are the top ten entries overall, and here is the winner of the super grand prize 2002

+-new CELL 557-+

Congrats Doc!!! Wow, second place...not bad. Kudos.

The Doc also came forth in the aesthetics section:
http://www.the5k.org/winners.asp/y=2002/t=10

Aesthetics and function - now that has to be good

Commiserations to InI and Poi (or is it poidesign? I don't know) - I suspect there was some dodgy voting going on there but this should give you the incentive to really blow them away next year

The overall winner was a bit of an odd choice - I saw better.

___________________
Emps

FAQs: Emperor

Wow 2nd!! and 4th places, Congrats Doc!!!



DS

Congrats Doc'

Emperor: that's POI


Some of the judges votes really puzzles me. I thought they would be harder to impress ( see most of the Fash entries, they are so... cheap, and looks so "Flash" )
For instance I don't understand how frutiger toy could have had the 1st place in orignality. Anyone that surfs the web a little has already seen that kind of thing hundred times, so where's the originality ?

Anyway, being honest to myself and seeing the public opinions I didn't expected to be in the top 5 of any category. But I thought WOLFENSTEIN 5K would came at least in the top 3 in originality.

well my opinion is surely biased. I guess I don't have same taste and sensitivity as the judges.


Whatever, I've already worked a couple of hours on 3D TOMB 2 and it's already bigger, better, faster than the 1st one. I hope I won't make the mistakes I did again.


Again, congrats Doc!

Mathieu "POÏ" HENRI

What was the contest about? It sounds like Flash games. If so I would've won every category. Not really. I've developing a Flash MMORPG with PHP4/MySQL.

Well, I was surprised and pleased to end up with the Overall #2 spot, that was cool. I also didn't really agree with some of the votes, the judges picked some strange things, and ranked things even odder. I actually snuck up the rankings a huge amount based on my size bonus, I only used 3k so I got a 4.3 point bonus! Without that I might not have even made the top 10. (As you already know, I'm a sneaky bastard, heh.)

I imagine the judges had a different definition of "function", I get the impression they were actually ranking "functionality", quite a different beast! This is the only way I can justify seeing 'Wolfentstein 5k' and 'Chess' ranked so poorly, just to mention the two most prominent. My scores were about what I expected, although I'm still chuckling about my 4.3 point jump, heh heh.

The "Overall winners" page is broken right now, it appears to be displaying last years winners in this years templates, hmm...

Your pal, -doc-

Go Doc! Whip the lama's ass!

Congrats



_________________________
Anyone who has lost track of time when using a computer knows the propensity to dream, the urge to make dreams come true and the tendency to miss lunch.
- copied from the wall of cell 408 -

I can't believe a freaking flash piece won.

That takes so much less effort and skill.



.:[ Never resist a perfect moment ]:.

I was kind of confused on some of the comments that were left there on your post Doc. Sounds like someone (or some people) were upset about "something". Anyway, Great Job!

Later,
C:\


~Binary is best~

mhm, yes i also wondered why frutiger won the grand price....hmmmm

+-new CELL 557-+

By the way, very nice, Doc.

I thought frutiger was really cool, but then I realized it was flash so it's not nearly as cool. I'm wondering, they don't take off any points for how much resources these things eat up, which I think they should personally. I think doc's was better than that frutiger one.

Maninacan Cell #471
behmer

Great job, Doc! I bet that feels good

. . : slicePuzzle

Yup- all the other top entries are in Flash. Doc, sticking to his programming roots- amazed the pants off the judges.

Good show!

CRO8

Congrats!

Woot !!
Way to go, Doc.