Preserved Topic: 100 guitarists of all time (Page 1 of 2)

hmmmm. what do you guys think? I think alot of people are disagreeing with this list from Rolling Stone


I am a big Allmans fan but Duanne at #2 over Clapton? Kurt Cobain at #12? I think hes more known for his voice/song writing than guitar skills. #17 jack white of white stripes? I wonder what their criteria was.

VH1 did a better job- I think they had

1. hendrix
2. clapton
3. bb king
4. jimmy page
5. duane allman
6. jeff beck



[This message has been edited by CRO8 (edited 01-03-2004).]

I totally disagree with that Rolling Stones list. I mean come one, Kurt Cobain ahead of Santana and Jeff Beck? Seems like a popularity contest to me. And even worse is Frank Zappa @ 45.

And where the hell is Malmstein? That guy rocks.

I haven't seen VH1's list, but it does seem better, although Jimmy Page should be down a few notches IMO.

In my opinion, a few glaring injustices:

Mark Knopfler (#27) is miles above many of the ones before him, as are

Les Paul (at #46, did a lot for electric guitar and gadgets and was as extremely good player himself)

Eddie Van Halen (at #70, extremely innovative and inluential whether it got old fast or not)

Criteria indeed? Apparently it was not not talent or influence, maybe it was a vote? I could see the results if there was voting involved, and that among different age groups.

quote:

---

And where the hell is Malmstein?

---

I dug a very deep hole, threw him in and filled it all up with concrete to spare the children from ever having to hear his name mentioned let alone his (widdly widdly) music.

That list is awful though - somewhere Kurt Cobain manages a brief giggle.

___________________
Emps

The Emperor dot org

Malmsteen? Chet Atkins rubbed him out so he could be on the list! No, wait, maybe that was Michael Hedges, no hold on. Phil Keaggy, ummmm, Leo Kottke? BAH!

I'm not a huge fan of AC/DC but 96. Angus Young of AC/DC?! Come on...

"Nothin' like a pro-stabbin' from a pro." -Weadah

wow, that is indeed a terrible, terrible list.

Oh, and I added sulphuric acid to Emperor's pit, just to be on the safe side...

Yes, Leo Kottke- just recently got one of his CDs . . .I know, Angus is at 96- ridiculous. Pisses me off. But I guess lists are supposed to cause arguments- this one goes out of its way.

DL:

quote:

---

Oh, and I added sulphuric acid to Emperor's pit, just to be on the safe side...

---

You are right to be cautious - experience shows that Scandinavian rock gods are so difficult to kill.

___________________
Emps

The Emperor dot org

I must have missed Joe Satriani's name in there somewhere. And Brian May only at #39? Puh-leez!

_____________________
le coeur du feu

Adam Jones of Tool...only #75?
btw my personal #1 would be john frusciante of red hot chili peppers

Clapton said Santana is God.

and where the hell is John Petrucci ?

I could stand to see Les Claypool on there since there seems to not be a top 100 bassist list.

what a joke.

the first three guitarists i looked for were:

Joe Satriani
Slash (guns 'n roses)
Ben Harper

Now, the third one i could handle not being in there, but ALL THREE were missing.

Bizzarre.



reitsma

Although I like his music... Jack White at 17?!?!?!

And where is Slash!?!?!?!

Certainly fits in above a lot of the other names on that list.

Jason

What's with all the pop and rock!! Have you never heard of:

Andreas Segovia: Andrés Segovia (1893-1987) is considered to be the father of the modern classical gutiar movement by most modern scholars. Many feel, that without his efforts, the classical guitar would still be considered a lowly bar instrument, played only by peasants.

and..
Narcisso Yepes
Paco De Lucia
Francisco Tarrega
Pepe Romero
Fernando Sor
D'jango Reinhart
Charlie Christian
Wes Montgomery
George Benson (early years.. pure be-bop)
Pat Metheny



[This message has been edited by Xpirex (edited 01-05-2004).]

Agree with Xpirex, there are some very glaring omissions. Steve Morse, Al Di Meola, Segovia should have been a certainty, Rory Gallagher. I can't imagine why Pat Metheny was left off. Jack White at 17? Kurt Cobain at 12? I dunno.. seems like a rock/pop popularity list to me, not the top guitar players.

Amerasu

popularity list.

yeah looks like a rock list. it's hard to judge things in such a broad topic as guitarist. Too many genres to go through.

not sure about Yeppes though Xpirex. That man had no tone. But yeah Segovia, Tarrega , Sor, Guiliani...those are some great "Classical" guitarists.
Had a lot to do with sculpting the guitar through the early part.

I think that's what they need to concentrate on. What they did for the genre they are playing in. Know what i mean?

Later,

C:\


~Binary is best~

[This message has been edited by CPrompt (edited 01-06-2004).]

Oh man.. I have some incredible Yepes albums... check out his rendition of -Bach: "Preludio", "Chaconne in D minor", and -Joaquín Rodrigo: "Concierto de Aranjuez" y "Fantasía para un Gentilhombre". Orquesta Sinfónica de RTVE, Odón Alonso.

quote:

---

His recordings are worldwide sold, but his endless research interest leads him to invent in 1964 the 10 strings guitar, and at the same time that he goes on his big career as concertist all over the world, he constantly works in the recovery and edition of old unpublished scores from the Renaissance, Baroque, etc., with more than 6000 works.

Applauded by the audiences all along the world, he has been a tireless traveller, giving concerts around the world. In 1980 he tours by the first time the former Soviet Union. From there he goes to Japan, where he gives 40 concerts and his art is really revered.

Concertist and teacher worldwide well know, he got many distinctions during his life:

1964 Favourite Son of the Town of Lorca

1964 Laurels of Murcia

1977 Doctor Honnoris Causa by the University of Murcia

1977 Member by Chapter and Honnour of the Royal Academy Alfonso X El Sabio from Murcia

1978 Favourite Son of the Region of Murcia

1984 Prize of the General Authors Society of Spain

1985 Prize of the Spanish Radio and TV Broadcasting

1986 National Prize of Music

1986 Counselor of the Higher Council for Culture and Fine Arts

1989 Member of the Royal Academy of Fine Arts of San Fernando

1989 Gold Medal of Lorca

Many other Spanish and foreign distinctions

Thanks to this universal lorquino and Murcian, as well to other great concertists from the 20th Century like Andrés Segovia and Emilio Pujol, the guitar has reached a big prestige as instrument.

Many composers made works for solo guitar or guitar and orchestra for Narciso Yepes, and he gave many premières

---

(And you say he has no tone?) Like Mozart's "Too many notes" hahahahahha


Those will be listened to in another 500 years still.. they have a timeless class.. they are historical... whereas most of your rock and pop folks will get forgotten. I guess it's an American favourites.. pop/rock list were' looking at here... This list is narrower than an ants arse.. Contrary to what the 'Rolling Stone' folks would have you believe the guitar was not invented in the 60's and it's main development had nothing to do with your English speaking peoples. Although I am humbled before Jimmy Hendrix.

I mean Kurt Cobain? who the hell is he? .. maybe he should be in the top 100 list of drug addicts and failures. You may as well include those donkey brains from "Bill and Ted's Incredible stupid waste of Time" movie.

I think Confucius said: " You can tell the quality and spirit and culture of a nation by the kind of music it listens too"



[This message has been edited by Xpirex (edited 01-06-2004).]

quote:

---

I mean Kurt Cobain? who the hell is he? .. maybe he should be in the top 100 list of drug addicts and failures. You may as well include those donkey brains from "Bill and Ted's Incredible stupid waste of Time" movie.

---

Prepare to die... slowly...

Kurt is good, but he shouldn't be that high on the list.

Well, the only thing I really feel like addressing is the one thing I would think would be extremely obvious -

Since this is Rolling Stone - the rock and roll magazine - we're talking about, it is fair to assume that their list is specific to rock/blues music as well.

I certainly won't disagree with the claims made about the poor quality of many of the guitarists on the list, or the superiority of a large number of classical guitarists, but I'm afraid that is totally irrelevent to the subject at hand.

Ok.. sorry for those that love Kurt.. but I'm sure you know what I mean...

DL-44: yes your right, ...I just got sucked in by the title of the post..

Xpirex : yeah.....he had no tone. I mean his sound was kind of strident at times. Not to say that he doesn't hold a place in the "Classical Guitar Hall of Fame" or anything beause he does, then again I don't like the way Segovia played Bach either.

Later,

C:\


~Binary is best~

Funny you say that as although Segovia is very higly regarded I find him a bit dry and lacking in passion too for my tastes. John Williams and Julian Bream as well..way t0o stiff and arid for me. I like a bit of fire and chilli pepper in my soup...

quote:

---

You may as well include those donkey brains from "Bill and Ted's Incredible stupid waste of Time" movie.

---

Say whatever you want about Kurt Cobain, but Billl & Ted are not to be taken lightly.

Andres Segovia

This first paragraph on that page is awefully familiar.

__________________
War is Peace,
Freedom is Slavery,
Ignorance is Strength.

dood, that is one bogus, hanus, and most NON-triumphant remark.

it's spelt heinous dUde! You just rubbed a little perperation H on yer anus is all you did, huh huh, huh. Rightchus!

dood, i knew it was like wrong... Wild Stallion!!!!

no
way

This is just like 100 best websites or something like that, which can never be a true list.
If you take a look, you can pretty much see only American and British names on this list. Not that I have something against them, but that just cannot be true, can it? What about Spanish guitarists for example?
In former Yugoslavia (now he lives in Macedonia), there is a guy Vlatko Stefanovski, he was in a band "Leb i Sol" ("Bread & Salt"), who is for me one of the best. He has been praised by masters like John McLaughlin, Allan Holdsworth, Joe Satriani and Mark Knoffler.
I was on his concert, what for an event!



Sasha »

Andrés Segovia is the greatest guitarist in the history of the guitar and he's not even on that list.

Rolling Stone Magazine is all about popularity--never trust it for good information.
http://www.arbitblatas.com/PorSeg.html

Well....again: this is Rolling Stone. An american based Rock mag.

It is going to feature artists who are well known in the american market in the rock/blues genre.

That is a given.

Now, within those limitations, there are plenty of wrongdoings with that list still.

But at least recognize that those are the limitations that this list is dealing with......

JK- thats pretty funny dude.

def a american popularity contest. for example, trey of phish (whether you like his music or not) is an outstanding guitarist playing with very good musicians- and you do not need to be on drugs to appreciate it. He is #73, while Warren Haynes who I do like (playing in 3 bands- Govt Mule, Allmans, and Phil & Friends)- who has made the radio in the last year- made #23. He did make guitar mag's slide guitarist of the year two years in a row (a few years ago) and is very good but #23 all time?

def a pop contest- but if so, how the hell did EVH drop to so far down the list? He hasnt been on teh charts in years . . .

I have lost all respect for RS and show it



[This message has been edited by CRO8 (edited 01-09-2004).]

I could probably figure it out by looking at their ads, but eh... what is their target market?

It seems this list is catered towards the casual music listener rather than the music fanatic or musician.

cro8 - I think the bigger problem is the quality of popular rock these days.

How can a magazine that has been top-notch for decades keep up the quality of their reporting if the quality of the music has - by and large - declined so greatly?

Of course, as with anything, if you look hard enough, and dig deep enough, you can find good things today.

But not like it was 20-30 years ago.....

In the 70's, you could toss a stone in any direction and hit a "rock god".

Nowadays, you have to dig through piles and piles of bullshit to even find a competent rock guitarist in popular music.

Although I agree with you 100% Dl....

It just means we are getting old.

Jason

good music never gets old - it just gets further and further away from whats popular . . . sad.

Ack! Sorry if this has been said already (didn't read em all)...

This list is truly a measure of mainstream popularity, not great guitarism. Kurt Cobain should not even be listed here, as his songs were mostly accidents that happened to sound cool and if you can be "cool" enough to fake a shit solo then it must be Rolling Stone magazine. Yes Joe Satriani is an instrumentalist, not a singer - where's he? Love Hendrix, but wouldn't list him at the top. White Stripes - pass me another break please. Tom Morello? - sure if you count multiple accompanying effects as being a "guitar."

Rolling Stone - another tabloid.

I'd rename this list to "Top 100 hook guitarists of all time"